| First Team |
|
|
| First Base |
Steve Walton |
Northern Kentucky |
| Second Base |
Chris Maynard |
Lewis |
| Shortstop |
Chad Opel |
SIU Edwardsville |
| Third Base |
Brian Fritzler |
Lewis |
| Catcher |
Jason Martin |
Northern Kentucky |
| Outfielder |
Tarron Acuff |
Indianapolis |
| Outfielder |
Garet Dinges |
Quincy |
| Outfielder |
Matt Guarnieri |
Indianapolis |
| Outfielder |
Justin Rahschulte |
Northern Kentucky |
| Designated Hitter |
Scott Schweitzer |
Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Starting Pitcher |
Lenny Bays |
Northern Kentucky |
| Starting Pitcher |
Rick Hummel |
Indianapolis |
| Starting Pitcher |
Josh Whaley |
Northern Kentucky |
| Starting Pitcher |
Blake Wyatt |
Indianapolis |
| Relief Pitcher |
Keith Wallace |
Missouri-St. Louis |
| Utility |
Scott Mertes |
Saint Joseph's |
| |
| Second Team |
|
|
| First Base |
Rhett Dwyer |
Lewis |
| Second Base |
Steve Polio |
Bellarmine |
| Shortstop |
Jeremy O'Neill |
Indianapolis |
| Third Base |
Pat Eschan |
Northern Kentucky |
| Catcher |
Kyle Scott |
Bellarmine |
| Outfielder |
Mike Eagen |
Saint Joseph's |
| Outfielder |
Mike Godfrey |
Lewis |
| Outfielder |
Steve Owen |
Southern Indiana |
| Outfielder |
Jim Reiter |
Missouri-St. Louis |
| Designated Hitter |
Brandon Hardy |
Saint Joseph's |
| Starting Pitcher |
Steve Arnold |
Southern Indiana |
| Starting Pitcher |
Andy Augsburger |
Saint Joseph's |
| Starting Pitcher |
Adam Gautreau |
Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Starting Pitcher |
Keith Nawrocki |
Saint Joseph's |
| Starting Pitcher |
Scott Schweitzer |
Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Relief Pitcher |
Tim Breuning |
Quincy |
| Relief Pitcher |
Eric Meyer |
SIU Edwardsville |
| Utility |
Wes Pickering |
SIU Edwardsville |
| |
| Player of the Year: Chad Opel, SIU Edwardsville |
| Pitcher of the Year: Lenny Bays, Northern Kentucky |
| Freshman of the Year: Steve Polio, Bellarmine |
| Freshman of the Year: Jarad Rettberg, SIU Edwardsville |
| Coach of the Year: Todd Asalon, Northern Kentucky |