| Sami Boudakh |
Lewis |
Junior |
Midfielder |
| Mark Coffee |
IUPU-Ft. Wayne |
Junior |
Back |
| John Coyle |
Lewis |
Junior |
Forward |
| Sean Cullen |
Bellarmine |
Senior |
Forward |
| Scott DeCuir |
Northern Kentucky |
Junior |
Midfielder |
| Lorenzo Delvecchio |
Lewis |
Junior |
Forward |
| Jamie Duvall |
Kentucky Wesleyan |
Junior |
Midfielder |
| Mike Eimers |
Bellarmine |
Junior |
Goalie |
| Kevin Geleott |
Saint Joseph's |
Junior |
Forward |
| Steve Glennon |
Lewis |
Sophomore |
Back |
| Sergio Greco |
Lewis |
Senior |
Forward |
| John Heerdink |
Southern Indiana |
Junior |
Back |
| Karsten Hojer |
Kentucky Wesleyan |
Freshman |
Forward |
| John Jensen |
Kentucky Wesleyan |
Freshman |
Midfielder |
| Andy McCulloch |
Southern Indiana |
Freshman |
Forward |
| Tom McSwigen |
Northern Kentucky |
Junior |
Midfielder |
| John Nugumya |
Indianapolis |
Freshman |
Back |
| Kevin O'Shaughnessy |
Saint Joseph's |
Junior |
Midfielder |
| Mirko Rimac |
Northern Kentucky |
Junior |
Midfielder |
| Chris Shust |
Bellarmine |
Senior |
Forward |
| Kevin Swords |
Southern Indiana |
Sophomore |
Forward |
| David Volz |
Southern Indiana |
Sophomore |
Forward |
Paragon Recipient: John Coyle, Lewis
Coach of the Year: Paul Rockwood, Northern Kentucky