| First Team |
Second Team |
| 1B - Adam Brechtl - UW-Parkside |
1B - Brent Miller - Indianapolis |
| 2B - Kyle Frangiamore - Indianapolis |
2B - Mike Umscheid - UW-Parkside |
| 3B - Mike Victor – Saint Joseph’s |
3B - Colby Hughes – Missouri-St. Louis |
| SS - Kory Lonergan – Northern Kentucky |
SS - Matt Reimer – Saint Joseph’s |
| UT - Matt Keener – Southern Indiana |
UT - Kevin Diete – Saint Joseph’s |
| DH - Josh Moulton – Northern Kentucky |
DH - Jason Strommen – UW-Parkside |
| OF - Josh Morgan – Missouri-St. Louis |
OF - Tim Baum – UW-Parkside |
| OF - Kevin Reynolds - Quincy |
OF- Noah Wetzel – Southern Indiana |
| OF - Bo Gum - Saint Joseph’s |
OF - Cory Bunner – SIU Edwardsville |
| OF - Ryan Kuhlman – Bellarmine |
OF - Alex Frank – Northern Kentucky |
| C - Conor McGeehan – Northern Kentucky |
OF - Sean McBride – Saint Joseph’s |
| SP - Mike Stitz - Saint Joseph’s |
C - Eric Caby – Quincy |
| SP - Cameron Cheek – SIU Edwardsville |
SP - Derrik Moeves – Northern Kentucky |
| SP - Brad Stone – Quincy |
SP - Matt Perdue – UW-Parkside |
| SP - Brandon Brooks – Kentucky Wesleyan |
SP - Paul Gagliardi – UW-Parkside |
| RP - Adam Zimmerman – Saint Joseph’s |
SP - Zach Hennings – Saint Joseph’s
SP - Erik Ping – Kentucky Wesleyan
RP - Todd Lorenz – UW-Parkside
|